Rashied Ali was/is a great drummer...but Elvin Jones was a stone cold genius and so perfect for that band. It's like how Phil Collins tried out for Zeppelin after Bonham died; you can't replace the irreplacable.
You can't really compare Jones and Ali - they are two completely different artists. Coltrane could not have done Interstellar Space or Stellar regions or Live At The Village Vanguard Again with Jones (or Tyner for that matter) - I'm not saying Jones wasn't a genius, I'm just saying that Ali swam in much different (and some would say deeper) waters and should be respected for his own work, not held up to Jones.
2 comments:
Rashied Ali was/is a great drummer...but Elvin Jones was a stone cold genius and so perfect for that band. It's like how Phil Collins tried out for Zeppelin after Bonham died; you can't replace the irreplacable.
You can't really compare Jones and Ali - they are two completely different artists. Coltrane could not have done Interstellar Space or Stellar regions or Live At The Village Vanguard Again with Jones (or Tyner for that matter) - I'm not saying Jones wasn't a genius, I'm just saying that Ali swam in much different (and some would say deeper) waters and should be respected for his own work, not held up to Jones.
Post a Comment